Elenadust’s Weblog

Lesetagebuch zu „Heat and Dust“

Arranged marriages Juni 22, 2008

Gespeichert unter: Nicht kategorisiert — elenadust @ 11:23

-          parents choose patners

-          bride and groom are forced to marry

-          early decision, early wedding (e.g. Gandhi with 13)

-          bride has to move in with her husband(‘s family)

ð     suffering, mother-in-law rules

-          often to be found in societies without equal rights for the sexes

-          factors in the decision: – colour of the skin

                                               - age

                                               - appearance      

                                               - no meetings before the wedding         

                                               - financial situation    

                                               - family’s reputation, cast and social status

-          often unhappiness follows

-          there is a dowry involved

 

Inder Lal’s antagonism Juni 22, 2008

Gespeichert unter: Nicht kategorisiert — elenadust @ 11:15

Traditional India:

-          Ritu’s treatment

-          Rule of mother

-          Arranged marriage

-          Interested in Hindu religion (believes in reincarnation)

 

Progress/Western influence:

-          strong interest in science

-          Rejection of hijras

-          Superstitious

 

Husband’s Wedding Day Juni 22, 2008

Gespeichert unter: Nicht kategorisiert — elenadust @ 10:08

Major Minnies

-          prevent disorder in Satipur on HWD -> duty: keep order

                                                   -> worried/ fear: afraid of losing control

 

Nawab (Muslim)

-          tolerates the Muslim-Hindu riots in Khatm on HWD -> ruler without power

                                                                                            -> shows the British their limits

                                                                                            -> refuses to follow advises

                                                                                            -> has religious motivation

                                                                                            -> takes offence at Hindu worshippers taking over 

                                                                                                 his ancestor’s shrine

Narrator

-          critical of festival

-          does not take it serious

-          does not see the sense

-          it is not what she expected

-          feels part of it; feels absorved

critisises:

-          overcrowded

-          noisy

-          fair/pleasant cutring

-          not religious anymore /lacks devoutness

 

Chid’s spirituality Juni 22, 2008

Gespeichert unter: Nicht kategorisiert — elenadust @ 9:44

-          is accepted to be a art of the town => is different

-          is not affected by the weather => ignorance

-          meditates for hours => deep faith

-          is chanting all the time => does not show consideration for the narrator and also Ritu

-          does not wash himself => makes his own rituals

-          does not take warnings serious => ignorance

-          through things from the narrator without permission away => ignorance

-          takes everything for granted e.g. the narrator’s room, her food, her money => no consideration or thankfulness

-          is consistent concerning possession

 

The big topics Juni 22, 2008

Gespeichert unter: Nicht kategorisiert — elenadust @ 9:28

pp. 49-61

 

-          sattee (shrines) -> reminds at Romeo and Juliet

-          the narrator, Inder Lal and his mother

-          the Nawab and Douglas

-          Inder Lal and his wife

 

=> arranged marriages

 

The Nawab’s image by Olivia Juni 22, 2008

Gespeichert unter: Nicht kategorisiert — elenadust @ 9:20

Analyse the different images of the Nawab by Olivia.

Support your results with quotations from the text (pp. 29-49) and present them on transparency.

 

p. 44, ll.18-19 => she is subordinated, she has to adapt to his mood

p. 44, ll. 27-32 => he is not considerate towards Olivia, she suffers, but he does not show     sympathy

p. 45, ll. 13-18 => he has mood swings

p. 48, ll. 11-12 => he is selfish, seem unapproachable, egoistic, but at the same time charming

p. 45, l. 29 – p. 46, l. 2: => ironic comments on Douglas, thus others has to accept his opinion, also if it is hurtful

 

Comments on the narrator’s behaviour and attitude Juni 22, 2008

Gespeichert unter: Nicht kategorisiert — elenadust @ 8:41

Read pages 24-28 verify or falsify the following statements by analysing the narrator’s behaviour. Quote from the text.

 

  1. The narrator is very pleased to meet her young compatriots.

             p. 25, l. 3: “odd trio” => sceptical

             p. 25, l.18: is interested in their stories, but not pleased

 

  1. The narrator holds her compatriots in high esteem. She admires their unselfishness and their brave decision to embark on a totally different life in India.

            p. 25, ll. 14-18: The English girl complains about the dirt in India and then the narraor

            asks the trio why they came to India => Ironic

            p. 25, l. 21: They have made so many bad experiences => Makes fun of them, why

            they are still in India

 

  1. The narrator is very interested in the young people she meets.

            p. 25, l. 18: If the narrator would not be interested, she would not write it in her diary    

      and would not ask the people why they are here, but these aspects have only a   

      meaning, because she is interested in their stories, but not in their personalities.

 

  1. The narrator is quite optimistic about the young people’s future in India.

             She makes fun of the English couple (look 2.) -> are overtaxed with life in India ->

             are not able to survive much longer

             p. 25, ll. 15-17: critical about the wave of Europeans who came to India to find

             spirituallity, but get only disillusionment; force them back to England, because they

             are not happy

 

  1. The narrator’s behaviour shows that she is totally different from Olivia.

            On the one hand, they are different, because Olivia is a bit like the unprepared English

            couple, who complains about their unhappiness. On the other hand, the narrator and

            Olivia react at the graveyard both touchy as they see the Saunder’s baby grave (p. 28,

            ll. 10-17).

 

Headlines Juni 22, 2008

Gespeichert unter: Nicht kategorisiert — elenadust @ 8:39

pp. 24-28

 

- Bad experiences

- Huge disappointment in India

- Positive and negative aspects of India

 

ð     The narrator just reflects the experiences of the others, but does not give her own opinion. Thus the reader has to form his own opinion.